Overview
Title: Original Black families and historical sites of Fort Collins, Colorado.
Topic: Black History, United States History, Community, Civil Rights, Race, Gender
Theme/Focus: Fort Collins Black History (People/Places)
Location(s): Fort Collins, Colorado.
Essential/Inquiry Question(s):
- Who were some of the founding Black people and families in Fort Collins?
- Why is it important to learn about racially diverse groups of people both locally and nationally/internationally?
*Images may be downloaded and will save in the highest resolution available from History Matters.
Author
Melanie Grande
Historical Context/Background
After the Civil War, the United States entered a significant period of transformation known as Reconstruction, which lasted from 1863 to 1877. During this time, the United States grappled with how to integrate millions of newly emancipated African Americans. Many beneficial things came out of Reconstruction, including the 13th Amendment that abolished slavery, the 14th Amendment that granted birthright citizenship, and the 15th Amendment that granted Black male suffrage by prohibiting states from denying the right to vote based on race, color, or previous enslavement.
Unfortunately, many of the advantages during Reconstruction were repealed, resulting in the creation of sharecropping and the crop lien system – both contributing perpetual debt and a severe lack of economic independence for African Americans–the establishment of Black Codes, the terrorist white supremacist group the Ku Klux Klan, and a overall lack of federal government involvement to enforce the Reconstruction amendments or to prevent the extra legal violence committed by white American against African Americans or seek justice after violence has been committed. By 1877, Jim Crow Laws, named after a minstrel show character, enforced racial segregation in public facilities, schools, housing, jobs, and continued to deny many of the rights given to African Americans during Reconstruction. Anyone who defied Jim Crow laws risked fines, arrests, violence, and even death. Jim Crow laws influenced the entire nation and were not limited to the Southern states. For instance, Jim Crow laws affected many of the founding Black families in Fort Collins, Colorado. Between the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, multiple Black families in Fort Collins faced the challenges of Jim Crow, which included a lack of mobility, limited job opportunities, segregated housing, and an overall lack of community in a white centric town. Each family or individual faced these challenges head-on and continued to live their lives despite the circumstances.
Due to segregation and travel exclusions, mobility was highly restricted for African Americans. Buses, streetcars, and railway compartments were all segregated. In written law or societal rules, black travelers were forced out of white compartments on various travel vehicles regardless of payment or status. White only businesses, including hotels, gas stations, restaurants, leisure sites, and more, refused service to African Americans. Travel discrimination became impossible to avoid even for those considered the Black elite such as Duke Ellington, Martin Luther King, Jr., or W.E.B. Dubois were all familiar with travel discrimination. Despite these restrictions, travel was still essential for African Americans. They may travel for employment, to attend school, to report for or return home from military service, to visit relatives, to tend to the sick and bury the dead, or to travel for fun and leisure. To navigate these segregated and dangerous spaces, an annual guidebook for African American roadtrippers was founded and published by New York City mailman Victor Hugo Green from 1936 to 1967. The Negro Motorist Green Book, or Green Book for short, was a guide for Black travelers that identified services and places friendly to African American travelers. It provided information on safe lodgings, businesses, and gas stations that would serve Black travelers along the road. Many Black families would also house Black travelers throughout the Jim Crow period. This was evident in early twentieth-century Fort Collins, Colorado. The home of an African American family, the Birdwhistles’, was not an official Green Book site but was known to house and accommodate Black travelers overnight. Whether directly named in Green Books or disseminated by word of mouth, the Black community came together to ensure safe travel across the segregated United States.
Another limitation of Jim Crow was the limitation on job opportunities. In the aftermath of the Civil War, the United States established economic and political systems that pushed capitalists and workers far apart, creating a large wealth gap. Many formerly enslaved Black workers who lacked education and finances were pushed into agricultural work and were forced to be sharecroppers or a part of a crop lien system, which became a perpetual cycle of being in debt to their employers who were often their former enslavers. This became a form of indentured servitude or those imprisoned to be least out to companies as convict laborers. In the North, African Americans could work in factories, as domestic servants, in unwanted low-paying jobs, or various trades for the few skilled workers. This was little improvement compared to the South due to Northern white Elites becoming the most powerful in the world through the further exploitation of African American workers. These limitations were prevalent for Black residents in Fort Collins, like Georgiana Coff, who worked for the family who had formerly enslaved her as a domestic servant, or for Charley Clay who worked as a “scavenger,” removing disposed items and trash off of public streets. Job opportunities were extremely limited, and African Americans were forced to work in unskilled and low-paying jobs that continued to exploit them.
Similarly, the Black families in Fort Collins who were limited in job opportunities were also limited in housing options. During Jim Crow, entire neighborhoods were segregated. Black families such as the Lyle family, the Thomas family, and Hicks family lived on the same streets and neighborhoods. Part of the reason these Black families and others lived near each other was due to redlining. This was a practice between the 1930s and 1960s, where African Americans were restricted from buying homes where predominantly white families lived. Areas redlined were often undesirable, locations of hazardous conditions, and perpetuated the wealth disparity between African Americans and white Americans. While these segregated living spaces were undesirable, the Black families that lived near each other were able to form strong community connections with one another. These connections were crucial so that the Black community could come together in a place where they belonged, could support each other, and have social connections.
The Black church was an integral place of connection for the Black community. It was a place of protection, practicality, activism, and spirituality. The Black church became a location where African Americans could gather for educational purposes, to arrange mutual aid groups or form political organizations. In Fort Collins, there were very few public spaces that allowed the Black community to come together. Therefore, like many other Black communities, the Clay family created their own spaces and opened their home as Zion Baptist Church congregation and a meeting place for other important social gatherings. Unfortunately, the Black church has been a target of racialized violence because it operated as an independent institution outside white control. White supremacist groups like the Ku Klux Klan would burn Black churches down. With the threat of violence, Black churches or other community spaces were at times limited and thus was a compelling factor for Black families to depart to cities that had more community spaces like the black church where they could come together socially and for support. Many of the funding Black families of Fort Collins left for this very reason. The lack of Black community spaces and the limited number of Black folks in the city were reasons to move to places that better suited their needs.
Resources
Birdwhistle Family
Description: The Birdwhistles were a part of the Great Migration. This mass movement of African Americans from the rural South to the urban North, Midwest, and West from 1910-1970 to escape racial violence and pursue educational and economic opportunities. Charles and Mamie Birdwhistle lived at 1005 W. Oak St. from 1920 to 1946, where they were the only Black residents on the block. Their home became an unofficial sanctuary for Black travellers passing through the area.
Possible Inquiry Questions:
- Why was it important for the Birdwhistles to open their home to other Black travelers passing through Fort Collins?
- How are the Birdwhistles similar to other Black families who also moved during the Great Migration?
Significance: Like many other African Americans during this time, job opportunities were limited to service jobs regardless of education level, skills, or talents. If an African American were to hold a job outside of the service industry, they were regarded as extraordinary and out of the norm by the white community. The Birdwhistle home was not an official Green Book site in Fort Collins; however, they were known to house and accommodate Black travelers overnight. Even in a place like Fort Collins, economic opportunities were restrictive to Black Americans, and the few places that accommodated Black travelers were other Black families like the Birdwhistles.
Georgianna Coff
Description: Photos from Georgianna and her unmarked grave alongside the Lunn family. Georgianna was enslaved by the Lunn family as a child and stayed with them after emancipation.
Possible Inquiry Questions:
- What was life like for African Americans post-emancipation?
- Why would an African American continue to work for the same family they were previously enslaved by?
Significance: Another connection to the legacies of slavery in Fort Collins. Georgianna continued to work with the family who enslaved her after emancipation and worked in similar domestic roles as she would have if she were still enslaved. She worked for the family while they resided in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and in Fort Collins, where she also worked for the L. R. Welch family. These service jobs were the few available to African Americans throughout the country and specifically in Fort Collins.
Mattie Lyle
Description: Mattie Lyle was a Fort Collins resident who successfully won a civil rights discrimination case in 1939 when she, her daughter, and a friend were denied entry into the State Theater in downtown Fort Collins (151 N. College Ave) in 1939.
Possible Inquiry Questions:
- In what way did the communities in Fort Collins fight for Civil Rights?
- Why is it important to recognize the efforts to end discrimination on a local level?
Significance: While lawsuits for discrimination were filed by numerous African Americans, it was considered rare for these lawsuits to be won and prove discriminatory practices. Civil Rights activism in Fort Collins helped continue to push the movement forward.
Hattie McDaniel
Description: Hattie McDaniel was an African-American singer, songwriter, actress, and civil rights activist. Her family briefly called Fort Collins home in the early twentieth century. The McDaniel family was one of the most well-known Black families in early Fort Collins History. In Hattie’s professional career, she worked as an actress and is known for being the first African American to win an Academy Award for her role in the 1939 film Gone with the Wind. She is also noted for her participation in Civil Rights activism in the 1945 “Sugarhill” lawsuits that ended restrictive racial covenants in her Los Angeles neighborhood.
Possible Inquiry Questions:
- In what way did Hattie McDaniel challenge the economic barriers placed on the African American community?
- Why was her role in Hollywood films seen as controversial?
Significance: Hattie McDaniel only lived in Fort Collins for a short period of time. However, knowing her family and her roots started here and moved to other prospects exemplifies the ways the Black community pursued their goals and did not let racial discrimination limit them from fighting for Civil Rights.


John Mosley
Description: John Mosley was born and raised in Denver, but chose to attend Colorado Agricultural College (later Colorado State University) in Fort Collins. Mosley was the first African-American to play on the university’s football team. After graduation, he served his country as a member of the renowned Tuskegee Airmen and continued to advocate for public health and anti-discrimination. He served in the Second World War, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War, and retired from the US Armed forces in 1967.
Possible Inquiry Questions:
- Who were the Tuskegee Airmen, and why were they important during WWII?
- What kind of difficulties would John Mosley face as the only African American on the college football team?
Significance: John Mosley’s life and accomplishments show how local people can play meaningful roles in larger national events.
Virgil Thomas
Description: Similarly to John Mosley, Virgil Thomas was a star Football player and served in the infantry in World War II. He was the only Black player on his football team and one of the few Black students in the school district. He was celebrated for his athletic skills in football and continued his education in college with a football scholarship.
Possible Inquiry Questions:
- Why did the Black families in Fort Collins live on the intersections of Meldrum and Cherry Streets?
- In what ways did Virgil Thomas’s athleticism help him in his educational and military career?
Significance: Despite being one of the few Black students in the Fort Collins school district, Virgil Thomas was still able to be athletically and academically successful.


The Green Book
Description: The Green Book listed businesses that would accommodate African Americans. This was crucial for Black travelers to ensure they could be accommodated and travel safely during the height of the Jim Crow era.
Possible Inquiry Questions:
- What is the Green Book, and why was it created?
- If the Green Book does not list safe accommodations in a place where African Americans are traveling, where do these travelers go or turn to?
Significance: The Birdwhistle home in Fort Collins was not an official Green Book listing. However, neighbors, family members, and Black travelers would stay at the Birdwhistle home knowing that it was a safe place where there was a community and they did not have to worry about businesses discriminating against them.